Skip to main content
← Back to articles

Delaware Avenue Residents Ask Livonia Council for Concrete Street at Oct. 26 Study Meeting

LIVONIA — 11/1/2026

Delaware Avenue residents asked the Livonia City Council on Oct. 26 to rebuild their street in concrete without a special assessment, and the request moved the $10.45 million 2027 road program to the regular agenda for Nov. 9. City Engineer Todd Zilincik recommended an asphalt overlay, which the packet estimates at about $500,000 less. No vote was taken. Study meetings set the agenda for the voting meeting, and all 16 items moved forward: 12 to the consent agenda and four to the regular agenda.

Six of the seven council members attended the study meeting in the City Hall Auditorium, 33000 Civic Center Drive, which followed that evening's regular meeting. Council President Kayleigh Reid said Council Member Eileen McDonnell attended the regular meeting and went home before the study session. Near the end of the meeting, City Attorney Eric Goldstein apologized to Reid and Council Member Brandon McCullough for advice given during the regular meeting's budget debate.

Significant events

City attorney apologizes for advice on ending debate

At the regular meeting, Goldstein said it was "at the discretion of the president to run the meeting" when Reid moved the budget to a vote over McCullough's request to respond to colleagues. Near the end of the study meeting, at about 1:14:23 in the meeting video, Goldstein said that advice was wrong.

"I was asked a question and I genuinely thought I knew and I was wrong," Goldstein said. "There was a protocol to end discussion that can be done. And because I gave you bad instruction, it wasn't done." Goldstein apologized to both Reid and McCullough and told McCullough, "I'm glad that my mistake did not result in silencing you." McCullough answered, "Apology accepted. Water under the bridge."

McCullough answers budget critics and reads a resume

McCullough opened council announcements at 6:43 with remarks McCullough said were cut off before the budget vote. McCullough said the instruction not to speak was given "illegally" under Robert's Rules of Order, with a point of order denied, and called the earlier criticism "an orchestrated colleague collaboration."

McCullough said the council must challenge the administration because of its past proposals, citing a Rotary pavilion construction proposal of more than $900,000 and the failure of a millage. McCullough also said:

  • The Noble Task Force, which McCullough said Council Member Carrie Budzinski brought in, is closed to other council members, and a request to the governmental affairs director to join went unanswered.
  • The budget lists nothing for the Alfred Noble Library.
  • McCullough asked only to chair the Capital Outlay and Infrastructure Committee and was told by the council president that five years on council had produced nothing.
  • A request for backup on $6.8 million in capital spending deserved an answer given the track record on buildings.

McCullough then read a professional history. It included work as facilities director in Northville Township, where McCullough described serving as owner's representative on a 98,000-square-foot essential services complex of about $39 million; as facilities director for the City of Novi, including a $9.8 million public works project and a $4 million gun range addition; and as director of construction for Macomb County Habitat for Humanity. McCullough's profile on the city website lists both the Northville Township and Novi jobs as facilities manager, and the Habitat job as director of construction. McCullough also listed awards from 2013 to 2021 and professional certifications and said, "Feel free to read the receipts." McCullough said anyone who calls the remarks "a ploy" to become the next mayor should look at the record: "I have a track record and I will get them done." When the remarks ended, Reid asked, "Anyone else want to read the resume?" No other member made an announcement.

Delaware Avenue: concrete or asphalt

The 2027 program lists Delaware Avenue as an asphalt rehabilitation in Section 34. The street is asphalt over old concrete, with about 36 homes along the segment, according to the packet. Residents brought a petition to the Citizens Road Advisory Committee on Oct. 7 asking for concrete. The committee kept the street on the list as asphalt and told them to bring the question to this meeting.

The limits of the segment differ by source. The Engineering letter and resident Robert Siffermann say West Chicago to Melrose. The program list says Florida Avenue to Melrose Avenue, with Blackburn Avenue listed from West Chicago to Florida.

The city's comparison, from the Engineering Department's handout and letter:

FactorAsphalt overlayConcrete reconstruction
Estimated cost, handout$200,000-$300,000$700,000-$800,000
Estimated cost, letterAbout $250,000About $750,000
Estimated cost, Zilincik at the meetingAbout $210,000 to $250,000Almost $500,000 more
Driveway access lostAbout 7 daysAbout 1 month
Construction timeAbout 2-3 weeksAbout 6-8 weeks
Typical life15+ years (handout); 15 to 20 years (letter); Zilincik gave both 15 to 20 years and another 20 to 25 years at the meeting30+ years, with an industry-wide surface scaling problem the handout says is structurally harmless
TreesCanopy staysMost would likely be removed
Who pays the differenceNot applicableProperty owners through a special assessment district based on frontage, likely over 15-20 years, including corner lots on Florida, Idaho, Texas, Iowa and Melrose

The handout's before-and-after tree images are labeled AI-generated and "not perfect." The letter says residents were also given the option to remove the street from the list "and go onto another street segment scheduled for 2028." It says the road has provided about 23 years of service; the handout says the asphalt was done in 2004, or 22 years ago.

Zilincik told the council the program rebuilds a road to its existing type. Zilincik said the cost difference would take other streets off the list and did not recommend waiting for concrete, citing an uncertain budget for 2028 and 2029. Reid asked about the residents' offer to wait a couple of years. Zilincik said the options were a special assessment on the 36 homes, based on frontage, or the overlay. The council holds "the purse strings," Zilincik said, and would have to name the street to cut. Zilincik pointed to Barkley and Hathaway avenues as segments already deferred from 2026.

Siffermann asked for concrete without an assessment or tax increase, saying other streets in the subdivision were rebuilt in concrete without one and that the street is an emergency bus route and priority snow route. A second Delaware resident said the street gets almost as much traffic as West Chicago and that an assessment would make a house hard to sell. Zilincik called West Chicago a collector and Delaware a 25-mph street, and offered traffic counts on both.

McCullough said concrete "is going to be better than asphalt" and agreed to Budzinski's request to name, in a formal email before Nov. 9, which streets to remove. Budzinski offered to put the item on consent. It went on the regular agenda so residents could speak on it again.

Road conditions and the $10.45 million program

The program covers 51 segments: 22 reconstruction, 15 rehabilitation and 14 maintenance. The budget is $5.05 million for concrete, $3.9 million for asphalt and $1.5 million for selective slab repair, the fifth year of the 10-year paving millage voters approved in 2022. Final street choices depend on bids in early 2027.

City staff rated 374 miles of road between July and September, 60.52 miles major and 313.47 miles local. The average PASER rating is 6.49, up from 5.96 in 2018. The share in poor condition rose from 2024:

  • Good (8-10): 31.06%, 116.17 miles, up from 28.8% and 108.11 miles.
  • Fair (5-7): 54.33%, 203.18 miles, down from 58.7% and 218.79 miles.
  • Poor (1-4): 14.50%, 54.21 miles, up from 12.3% and 46.18 miles.

Separate from the program, the packet says Wayne County plans 2027 work on Middlebelt Road from Schoolcraft to Five Mile and resurfacing of Six Mile from Haggerty to Levan, and MDOT plans to finish restoration and landscaping on I-96 and M-14 between Sheldon and Newburgh roads. Zilincik told the council the Six Mile work runs from Levan to Newburgh. Zilincik said Inkster Road from West Chicago to Schoolcraft is finishing in early November; the Oct. 7 committee agenda said late October.

Robot inspection pilot for water mains

The Department of Public Works proposes a $19,125 pilot with Motmot Inc. of Detroit, which sends a tethered, self-propelled robot into live water mains through fire hydrants. Assistant Director of Public Works Zach Haapala said it is unusual to bring an expenditure under $20,000 to the council, and that the item was brought forward to show the technology. Motmot's list price is $42,500, less a 55% pilot discount, for inspections at Plymouth and Merriman roads (up to 264 feet), Plymouth and Farmington roads (up to 465 feet) and Stark Road and Schoolcraft (up to 585 feet), with a report within 10 business days.

Operations Director Tim Slusser presented interior video showing tuberculation in a cast iron pipe and said the company works with Detroit, Fenton, Adrian and Sault Ste. Marie. Slusser said one recent inspection of about $25,000 led an unnamed neighboring community to defer more than $2 million of a planned roughly $3 million replacement. Haapala said Motmot founder Elliot Smith graduated from Livonia Franklin. Haapala said Public Works would return to discuss wider use if the pilot goes well. Council Vice President Patrick Brockway asked about propulsion, and a Motmot representative described two independently driven impellers. Motmot's chief development officer also attended.

Statements at the meeting and the packet differ on several points:

  • System size: Haapala said more than 500 miles of main and more than 10,000 valves and hydrants. The Public Works letter says almost 500 miles and close to 10,000.
  • Patents: Haapala said about seven or eight patents, and the letter says "patented device." Motmot's proposal says "7 patents pending."
  • Valve replacement cost: Haapala said upwards of $100,000 for a valve like the one being replaced at Schoolcraft and Newburgh. The letter says hundreds of thousands of dollars, and upwards of $1,000,000 for all three locations.
  • Tether reach: Slusser gave both 800 feet in ideal conditions and a 900-foot tether.
  • What the data shows: The letter cites Lidar for wall thickness and Slusser said the data can help determine a pipe's life expectancy. The proposal lists video, pressure, acoustic and position data, and excludes structural analysis, remaining useful life and any certification that a pipe is fit for service.
  • Dashboard: Slusser described a data dashboard. The proposal's deliverables list inspection files, a condition report and a GIS package.
  • Company address: The proposal and Public Works letter say 2050 15th Street, the proposal letterhead says 2150 15th St., and a patent filing says 1050 15th Street.

The proposal says its price is valid for 21 days from Oct. 8, a period that ends before the Nov. 9 vote. The city would prepare hydrants and handle valves, traffic control and any water testing.

Streetlight conversion: two figures for the city's cost

The project converts 1,542 high-pressure sodium and mercury vapor streetlights to LED at a total of $680,173.49, of which DTE contributes $100,230 and the city pays $579,943.49. A $463,955 Carbon Reduction Program grant through the Southeast Michigan Council of Governments (SEMCOG) and an anticipated $52,209 DTE rebate come back afterward.

  • Final city cost: the Engineering letter says $15,988.49. Zilincik said $63,779.49. The letter's other figures, $527,735 less the grant, come to about $63,780.
  • Payback: the letter says 2.72 years. Zilincik said four months. Estimated energy savings are $194,000 a year in the letter and just under $200,000 from Zilincik.
  • Project total: the Oct. 22 budget memo from Finance Director Benjamin Grier budgets $700,173 for LED replacement, with $616,300 in grants from SEMCOG and DTE.

The letter warns funding may not be available after Dec. 11 without a federal continuing resolution, and Zilincik said the project must be obligated by then. The resolution would authorize $580,000 from account 401-000-987-000.

$5 million for lead service lines

OHM Advisors' $35,000 contract amendment would prepare the paperwork and bid documents for $5 million from the Drinking Water State Revolving Fund, awarded through the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE). Haapala said the money would speed up identifying service line material across the rest of the city and replacing any lead lines. The letter says it could end the need for $1.7 million budgeted each year, and federal rules require all lead lines replaced by 2031. OHM's schedule shows a bid opening March 8, 2027, and construction starting around April 2027, with completion within EGLE's three-year timeframe. The same schedule lists authorization on Oct. 25, the day before this meeting.

Budzinski asked whether residents are still responding to the city's Check Your Pipes Livonia program. "Not a ton," Haapala said. A contractor on the cross-connection program, due at committee, would also confirm service line material inside homes.

Agenda table

The council votes on these items Nov. 9. "Consent" means the items are expected to pass in one motion unless a member pulls one. Placement is direction from the council, not an approval.

ItemDescriptionDetails and discrepanciesOct. 26 status
Approved
NoneA study meeting takes no final action. Nothing was approved.Not applicable
Denied
NoneNothing was denied, and no item was held or removed from the agenda.Not applicable
Unfinished business
NoneThe agenda listed no unfinished business.Not applicable
New business: consent agenda, Nov. 9
1. Turnout gear12 sets of Honeywell Morning Pride TAILS coats and pants for Livonia Fire & Rescue, from MES, Inc., under Sourcewell contract 010424-MES. $42,206.28, or $3,517.19 a set. Account 101-338-768-000.Bidding waived as cooperative purchasing. Chief Robert Jennison said this is the department's usual vendor. The attached quote, QT2121697, lists an Oct. 22 expiration and says actual shipping will be added.Consent
2. LUCAS chest compression systemOne hands-free CPR device with protection plan from Stryker Sales, LLC, sole source. $29,895.46: $23,604.06 equipment, $5,926.40 ProCare and $365 shipping. Account 101-338-742-000.The letter says a five-year protection plan. The quote's ProCare dates run Oct. 15, 2026, to Oct. 14, 2030. Matches units on frontline apparatus.Consent
3. Trimble Unity Maintain softwareReplaces Cityworks AMS Standard Online with 150 logins with Trimble Unity Maintain Elite with unlimited users, for DPW work orders, complaints, equipment, fuel, payroll and water and sewer assets. Sole source. Split equally between the Refuse and Water funds.Year 1 $115,631.46; Year 2 $153,090; Year 3 $165,337.20; about $434,059 over three years (sum of the three). The agenda gives a term through Feb. 28, 2030; the letter gives Nov. 30, 2029. After that, the order renews automatically for 12-month terms, and Trimble has the right to raise fees at each renewal by the greater of CPI plus 2% or 8%. Douglas Moore of Public Works said the system came online in 2016; the letter says adopted in 2017. The city's letter lists Moore as assistant director; OHM documents list Moore as interim director of Public Works.Consent
4. 2027 Ford F-550 stake truckTruck #65 for Public Works. $69,556 from Lunghamer Ford of Owosso through state and Macomb County contracts, plus $49,620 upfitting by Truck & Trailer Specialties, Inc., Howell, on a Rochester Hills contract. $119,176 total. Account 401-000-985-010.Upfit includes an 11-foot flatbed, water tank and pump, toolboxes and a Boss 9'2" V-plow. The letter says the truck goes to the Roads construction crew and replaces a unit past its service life. Moore said the old truck was in forestry and went to auction because repairs exceeded its value.Consent
5. OHM Advisors, lead service linesContract amendment, not to exceed $35,000, for design and planning on the $5 million state revolving fund award. Account 592-559-818-000.Work covers Sections 1, 2, 11-16, 19-24 and 30-36. Construction engineering would come in a separate supplement. See Significant events.Consent
6. Motmot water main pilotSole-source inspection at three locations for $19,125, from unexpended FY 25-26 capital funds.Additional field days are $12,500 each with written authorization. See Significant events.Consent
11. OHM Advisors, Newburgh RoadContract amendment, not to exceed $109,258, for design of the rehabilitation from Plymouth Road to Amrhein Road. Includes $14,400 for SME pavement cores and $8,900 for SWCA historic review. Account 204-447-818-102.Mill, base repairs, 3 inches of new asphalt, ADA ramps and markings. Federal aid is $1,063,786 in the letter. The city seeks to advance the FY 29 money to 2028 because of traffic diverted by MDOT projects. The letter gives 81.85% federal and 18.85% city, which total 100.7%. Length is 2,625 feet in the letter and 2,620 feet in OHM's scope. OHM's schedule: MDOT letting Dec. 3, 2027; construction May 8 to Sept. 8, 2028.Consent
12. DTE LED streetlight conversionConverts 1,542 streetlights. $579,943.49 contribution-in-aid to DTE; $580,000 authorized from account 401-000-987-000.Includes 66 mercury vapor lights of various wattages and sodium lights of 100, 250 and 400 watts. See Significant events for the two city cost figures.Consent
13. Streetlight, Newburgh south of Eight MileCode 82 silver post and 136-watt LED fixture by DTE near the Greenmead Historical Park and Whispering Willows Golf Course entrances. $4,319.55 total, less a $1,227.48 DTE credit: $3,092.07 from account 101-447-818-600, plus an estimated $409.16 a year in electrical charges.The agenda and letter say one light on the west side. Zilincik said one new light on the east side at the Tin Cup and Whispering Willows drive and an upgrade to the existing west-side light. Council Member Robin Persiconi asked whether the light is needed once a Sheetz is built at the corner. Zilincik said Sheetz lighting may be a year away and is limited by ordinance, and that the light is a first step toward a possible refuge island crossing.Consent
14. Storm water agreement, Farmington RoadClean Express Auto Wash, LLC, 20340 Farmington Road, N.W. ¼ of Section 3. Accepts the storm water system and makes the company responsible for reimbursing the city for maintenance.Wayne County permit M26-0081. The Engineering Division approved the plans.Consent
15. Storm water agreement, Plymouth RoadClean Express Auto Wash, LLC, 34835 Plymouth Road, N.W. ¼ of Section 33. Same terms as item 14.Wayne County permit M26-0079. The Engineering Division approved the plans.Consent
16. Sidewalk waiver, LathersBrian and Brittany Holt, 18101 Lathers Street, S.E. ¼ of Section 12.Engineering recommends the waiver because the area has no sidewalks and has open ditches on both sides, and the city has no plans to build any there in the near future.Consent
New business: regular agenda, Nov. 9
7. 2027 Road Repair Program51 segments, $10.45 million, reviewed by the Citizens Road Advisory Committee, which recommended it Oct. 7 with eight members in favor and one absent.Committee attendance from the public is 12 in the letter; Zilincik said 10. Unpaved roads are 1.5 miles in the letter and 0.43 miles in the committee agenda. Amrhein Road federal aid for 2027 is $917,743 in the letter and $975,000 in the committee agenda. See Significant events.Regular
8. OHM Advisors, Contract 27-AAsphalt program design for 15 segments, not to exceed $167,700, 4.3% of $3.9 million in construction. Account 204-447-818-102.OHM's schedule starts road construction May 3, 2027. Delaware Avenue is in this contract's list. Zilincik said bidding in February or March avoids waiting until summer.Regular
9. AEW, Contract 27-CAnderson, Eckstein & Westrick, Inc., concrete program design for 22 segments, not to exceed $217,500, on $5.05 million in construction. Account 204-447-818-102.Includes Barkley and Hathaway avenues, deferred from 2026. Brockway asked whether staff could do the work. Zilincik said the division has a staff of 10 and would need more engineers and testing capacity.Regular
10. AEW, Contract 27-JConcrete maintenance and selective slab design for 14 segments and up to 25 other locations, not to exceed $79,500, on $1.5 million in construction. Account 204-447-818-102.A major portion is westbound Schoolcraft now that MDOT's I-96/M-14 work is ending. Zilincik said the consultant selection contract expires at the end of "this month" under item 9 and at the end of November under item 10; the letters say it runs through fiscal 2026.Regular

Vote record

The council took no votes on Oct. 26. Each row below is direction from a member on where an item goes, accepted without objection from another member. The votes are pending for the 2052nd regular meeting on Nov. 9.

Times are elapsed from the start of the meeting video. Present: Budzinski, Persiconi, Ptashnik, Brockway, McCullough and Reid. Absent: McDonnell.
TimeItemMember offering directionPlacement
13:561. Turnout gearRobin PersiconiConsent
14:462. LUCAS systemCarrie BudzinskiConsent
17:513. Trimble softwareMartha PtashnikConsent
19:044. Stake truckRobin PersiconiConsent
21:525. OHM, lead service linesCarrie BudzinskiConsent
35:036. Motmot pilotCarrie BudzinskiConsent
43:497. Road programCarrie Budzinski offered consent; moved to regular at 44:44 at a member's requestRegular
53:258. OHM, 27-AMember not identified in the transcriptRegular
54:529. AEW, 27-CMartha PtashnikRegular
58:2210. AEW, 27-JPatrick BrockwayRegular
1:01:2611. OHM, Newburgh RoadMartha PtashnikConsent
1:04:0312. LED conversionBrandon McCulloughConsent
1:11:1413. Newburgh streetlightMember not identified in the transcriptConsent
1:13:0214. Storm water, Farmington RoadMember not identified in the transcriptConsent
1:13:1715. Storm water, Plymouth RoadMember not identified in the transcriptConsent
1:13:5816. Sidewalk waiverMember not identified in the transcriptConsent

Public comment timeline

TimeSpeakerComment
First audience communication (non-agenda items)
1:11Bob, LivoniaSaid Friday trash pickup was unreliable through the summer yard waste season and that Priority Waste drivers blamed equipment breakdowns. Proposed every-other-week recycling by odd and even addresses after yard waste ends, as in a Northville neighborhood, so trucks can be repaired over the winter. Tied a shortage of mechanics to the loss of school shop classes.
4:16Elijah, LivoniaSaid Priority Waste is a problem in other cities too. Asked what the council can legally do about the Flock camera contract: whether it can vote to cancel it, defund it to $0 and override a mayoral veto. No one answered at the meeting.
5:06Erica Jones, LivoniaSaid this was the first meeting attended and that what happened at the meeting that night was disappointing, comparing it to nurses keeping disagreements away from patients. Asked that an issue with a homeowners association be addressed.
Item 6, Motmot pilot
37:00ElijahCalled it an investment that will reduce future costs. Asked who owns the software, whether it is a one-time payment or a renewing subscription, and whether terms can change. No one answered at the meeting. The proposal lists a $19,125 fee invoiced on delivery and does not mention a subscription.
Item 7, road program
45:24Robert Siffermann, Delaware AvenueA 27-year resident and 20-year homeowner, speaking for residents on and near the street. Asked for concrete without a special assessment or tax increase. Called the street an emergency bus route and priority snow route. Said residents would accept a delay and have gathered signatures.
47:40Delaware Avenue resident since 1986A 41-year Livonia resident. The transcript does not capture the name; the packet names Eric Greenslade as a Delaware representative living there since 1986. Said the street gets almost as much traffic as West Chicago, residents pay the millage and young families and people on fixed incomes cannot afford an assessment. Questioned leaving a faulting curb section next to one marked for replacement.
Item 12, LED conversion
1:04:15Melissa, LivoniaAsked where the line items are published and was pointed to the online packet and a QR code in the auditorium. Said street lighting is sufficient, questioned paying $63,000 more and said LED light seems too bright.
1:05:17Denise Mika, LivoniaAsked whether neighborhood lights are included and whether residents who pay for lights through their taxes would see a reduction. Zilincik said the lights are mainly on major roads with some in subdivisions, and that any change would be determined through the December tax bills.
Item 13, Newburgh streetlight
1:11:39Sandy Fleming, LivoniaSaid the item describes one light on the west side while the discussion covered lights on both sides, and suggested it might belong on the regular agenda. Zilincik answered that one light is new and the existing one is upgraded.
Closing audience communication (non-agenda items)
1:16:13Steve King, Coventry GardensSaid the budget process starts with council questions at the podium, and that the consent agenda approves millions of dollars without them. Said items over $100,000 should not go on consent, a policy King said was changed during King's time on the school board. Was asked twice from the dais to stay off agenda items, including lead lines and LED lighting. Said LED lighting uses 90% less energy and urged the same change at the existing library. Told the council to ask departments for 10% less.

Council member updates timeline

TimeSpeakerUpdate
0:32Kayleigh Reid, presidentOpened the meeting. Said tonight's items go to a vote Nov. 9 and that McDonnell had gone home after the regular meeting.
6:43Brandon McCulloughResponded to criticism from the regular meeting, listed concerns about capital spending and the Noble Task Force and read a professional history. Details are under Significant events.
13:17Kayleigh Reid, presidentAsked whether anyone else wanted to read a resume. No other member announced anything.
21:52Carrie BudzinskiDuring item 5, reminded residents to sign up through Check Your Pipes Livonia for an in-home check of the service line, and said the visit at the Budzinski home took about two minutes.
1:06:42Brandon McCulloughDuring item 12, said an upcoming committee meeting will address LED color temperature in the ordinance. Said the brightest fixtures are "like a tanning booth."
1:15:42Brandon McCulloughAccepted Goldstein's apology.
From staff
14:58Robert Jennison, fire chiefAnnounced a Livonia First Responder Foundation fundraiser for National First Responder Day, Oct. 28, 11 a.m.-1 p.m. at Laurel Manor. The foundation helps responders and residents hit by tragedy.
1:14:23Eric Goldstein, city attorneyApologized to Reid and McCullough for advice at the regular meeting.

What's next

  • Before Nov. 9: McCullough's email naming streets to remove from the concrete program. Zilincik offered traffic counts on Delaware and West Chicago.
  • Nov. 9: 2052nd regular meeting, with votes on all 16 items. Residents may speak on the road program.
  • Dec. 11: date after which LED conversion funding may not be available without a federal continuing resolution.
  • Early 2027: bids on the road program.
  • March 8, 2027: bid opening on OHM's schedule for lead service line work.
Comments
Loading...

Log in to comment.