Livonia council denies Jiffy Lube rezoning 5-2, approves 2027 road program, tables Emerson Oaks bond release
LIVONIA — 11/14/2026
The City Council denied a request to rezone a vacant Seven Mile Road parcel for a Jiffy Lube, denied a parking rezoning for the Fountain Bleu Health and Rehabilitation Center, approved the $10.45 million 2027 road repair program and put off a bond release for the Emerson Oaks site condominium after residents described unfinished work.
The Jiffy Lube vote
Council voted 5-2 on Nov. 9 to deny Petition 2026-06-01-02, a request from Guggenheim Development, LLC to rezone 32520 Seven Mile Road, a vacant 1.32-acre parcel at the northwest corner of Seven Mile Road and Mayfield Avenue, from C-1 (Local Business) to C-2 (General Business) for a Jiffy Lube automotive service center. Councilmembers Martha Ptashnik and Brandon McCullough voted no on the denying motion. The City Planning Commission had recommended denial on Aug. 11.
Councilmember Carrie Budzinski offered the denying motion. She said the area near Seven Mile and Farmington Road has seen walkable new businesses next to apartments and homes, and said a C-2 designation was not appropriate there. She said she lives on the south side of the city, where many auto-related businesses operate, and said, "It really breaks up the environment."
Elizabeth Rogers, counsel for the developer with Taft Stettinius & Hollister in Southfield, said the developer had offered a recorded statement of conditions under which the C-2 zoning applies only to the Jiffy Lube site plan and is void if that project is not built, and said 23 letters of support had been submitted. Tim Rossi of Guggenheim Development said the company builds and opens Jiffy Lube stores rather than holding land for resale. Jason Daye of Excel Engineering said a store services 30 to 35 vehicles a day with four to five employees, about four vehicles an hour, split between a driveway on Mayfield Avenue and a connection through the plaza to the west.
Five members of the public spoke. Jim Biga, Jerry Karasinski, Cindy Fleming and Denise Mika opposed the rezoning, citing nearby apartments, memory care and assisted living facilities, school bus stops and the precedent of C-2 zoning. John Pastor, who owns the Scooter's Coffee property at 19100 Farmington Road, spoke in favor.
McCullough asked whether the zoning could be conditioned to revert to C-1 if the property were sold. A city official answered that voluntary conditions offered by an applicant are legally enforceable, and a speaker for the developer said the developer would agree to that condition. McCullough said he would not support the denial, calling the parcel long vacant and the company's buildings "very tasteful," and said, "I think this is a bad decision."
Fountain Bleu parking rezoning denied
Council voted 7-0 to deny Petition 2026-06-01-01 from Optalis Healthcare, which asked to rezone the rear 25 feet of five Camden Avenue lots (11687, 11709, 11731, 11741 and 11755 Camden) from N-1 (Neighborhood) to C-1 (Local Business) for added parking at the Fountain Bleu Health and Rehabilitation Center on Plymouth Road. The Planning Commission had recommended approval 5-1 on Aug. 11.
Vice President Patrick Brockway, who offered the denial, said the petitioner was not at the meeting when the item came up, that council had questions about debts owed to the city, and that a P (Parking) designation would make more sense than C-1, which could allow other uses if the site changed hands.
2027 road program approved, Delaware stays asphalt
Council approved 7-0 the 2027 Road Repair Program, the fifth year of the ten-year paving millage, as reviewed by the Citizens Road Advisory Committee. The packet budgets $10.45 million: $5.05 million for concrete reconstruction, $3.9 million for asphalt and $1.5 million for selective slab maintenance, across 51 street segments. Council then approved 7-0 each of three design contracts: OHM Advisors for the asphalt program ($167,700), and Anderson, Eckstein & Westrick for the concrete program ($217,500) and the selective slab program ($79,500).
Residents of Delaware Avenue had petitioned for concrete reconstruction instead of the planned asphalt overlay. Budzinski put the asphalt work at about $250,000 and concrete reconstruction at about $750,000, and said the engineering department considered asphalt sufficient for the street's traffic. The city engineering letter describes the segment as Delaware from West Chicago to Melrose; the proposed program list shows Delaware from Florida Avenue to Melrose Avenue. Budzinski said she walked the street and was supporting the committee's recommendation. McCullough said he would approve the program and noted the bids return to council for approval. City Engineer Todd Zilincik said the program would go out with Delaware as an asphalt overlay and that asphalt and concrete awards would come back to council.
Emerson Oaks bond release tabled
Council voted 7-0 to table until Nov. 23 the release of $38,300 in development bonds for the Emerson Oaks site condominium at 28400 West Chicago, the former Wilson Elementary School site. McCullough first moved to deny the release, citing a homeowners association list of about 26 items, then withdrew that motion in favor of tabling.
Three residents described a crumbling road four years after paving, a berm too steep to mow, flooding at the northwest corner, a loose monument sign, missing and dead trees and poor grass in the common areas. Zilincik said the engineering items tied to these bonds are complete and the road is accepted into the city's Act 51 system. City Attorney Eric Goldstein said each bond secures specific work and the city "can't hold bond money hostage" once that work is done. Council President Kayleigh Reid asked members to send questions to staff by the end of the week.
Other business
Council approved the 12-item consent agenda 7-0, including a $579,943.49 payment to DTE Energy to convert 1,542 streetlights to LED, which the engineering letter says nets to a city cost of $15,988.49 after a $463,955 SEMCOG Carbon Reduction Program grant and an expected DTE rebate. The letter's own figures, the $579,943.49 payment less the $52,209 rebate and $463,955 grant, net to about $63,780, not $15,988.49. It also approved a $19,125 pilot with Detroit's Motmot, Inc. to inspect three live water mains by robot.
Council gave first reading to a Spartan National LLC rezoning on Farmington Road between Seven Mile and Gable, released $10,000 in bonds for the Lyndon Park site condominium, added $20,000 to the 2026 sidewalk trip-hazard cutting contract, voted to send kratom to the Public Safety and Health Committee and scheduled a closed Committee of the Whole meeting on Schostak/MPV's request to amend a consent judgment. The first reading took no vote; each of the others passed 7-0.
Tribute and recognition
Reid opened the meeting with a moment of silence for Gordon St. John, who served 37 years on the Livonia Traffic Commission and died in October.
Ptashnik then read a letter from a couple whose home burned on Oct. 10, 2026, while they were on vacation, thanking Fire Marshal Brian Kukla. The letter said Kukla walked them through the house, held the keys to the boarded-up home, stayed with them on his day off after the house was broken into the next day and kept them updated over the following week. Kukla, who the fire chief said has served with the department 26 to 27 years, received a certificate of appreciation. His wife and daughter attended.
All agenda items
| # | Item | Details from the agenda packet | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fire turnout gear | 12 sets of Honeywell Morning Pride TAILS coats and pants from MES, Inc. through the Sourcewell cooperative contract, $3,517.19 a set, $42,206.28 total, from budgeted fire funds. | Approved |
| 2 | LUCAS chest compression system | One LUCAS 3.1 device with a five-year ProCare protection plan from Stryker, the sole-source provider, $29,895.46. Matches units already on front-line apparatus. | Approved |
| 3 | DPW work management software | Sole-source renewal moving Cityworks to Trimble Unity Maintain Elite with unlimited users: prorated Year 1 $115,631.46, Year 2 $153,090.00, Year 3 $165,337.20, split between the Refuse and Water funds. The agenda heading says the term runs through Feb. 28, 2030; the department letter gives Dec. 1, 2026, to Nov. 30, 2029. Trimble may raise fees at renewal by the greater of CPI plus 2% or 8%. | Approved |
| 4 | Stake truck | 2027 Ford F-550 4x4 stake truck (Roads #65) from Lunghamer Ford of Owosso through state contract, $69,556, plus upfitting by Truck & Trailer Specialties of Howell, $49,620, for $119,176 total. Replaces a decommissioned unit. | Approved |
| 5 | Lead service line design | Amendment to the OHM Advisors engineering contract, not to exceed $35,000, for planning and bid documents for the 2027 lead service line replacement project. OHM's letter says EGLE awarded the city $5 million from the Drinking Water State Revolving Fund. | Approved |
| 6 | Live water main inspection pilot | Sole-source pilot with Motmot, Inc. of Detroit, whose hydrant-launched robot inspects pressurized mains, at three sites: Plymouth and Merriman, Plymouth and Farmington, and Stark and Schoolcraft. $19,125 after a 55% pilot discount on $42,500. | Approved |
| 7 | Newburgh Road design | OHM Advisors design contract, not to exceed $109,258, for rehabilitating Newburgh Road from Plymouth Road to north of Amrhein Road (about 2,625 feet). The city was approved for $1,063,786 in federal funds for FY 2029 and plans to advance construction to summer 2028. The letter puts the federal share at 81.85% and the city share at 18.85%, figures that together exceed 100%. | Approved |
| 8 | LED streetlight conversion | Contribution-in-aid payment of $579,943.49 to DTE Energy to convert 1,542 high-pressure sodium and mercury vapor streetlights to LED; total project $680,173.49 with a $100,230 DTE contribution. After a $463,955 SEMCOG Carbon Reduction Program grant and an expected $52,209 rebate, the letter puts the city's cost at $15,988.49; its own figures ($579,943.49 less the rebate and grant) come to about $63,780. It estimates energy savings of $194,000 a year. | Approved |
| 9 | Newburgh streetlight | One new streetlight on the west side of Newburgh Road south of Eight Mile, near the Greenmead Historical Park and Whispering Willows Golf Course entrances. City cost $3,092.07; estimated annual electric charge $409.16. | Approved |
| 10 | Storm water agreement, 20340 Farmington | Storm water facilities maintenance agreement with Clean Express Auto Wash, LLC, which reimburses the city for any needed maintenance (Wayne County permit M26-0081). | Approved |
| 11 | Storm water agreement, 34835 Plymouth | Same agreement with Clean Express Auto Wash, LLC for its Plymouth Road site (permit M26-0079). | Approved |
| 12 | Sidewalk waiver, 18101 Lathers | Waiver of the sidewalk requirement for Brian and Brittany Holt. Engineering recommended it because the area has no sidewalks and open ditches on both sides of the street. | Approved |
| # | Item | Details | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13 | 2027 Road Repair Program | Fifth year of the ten-year paving millage. $10.45 million budget ($5.05 million concrete, $3.9 million asphalt, $1.5 million selective slab), 51 segments: 22 reconstruction, 15 rehabilitation, 14 maintenance, plus 25 miscellaneous locations to be set by DPW and Engineering. Includes Barkley and Hathaway avenues, deferred from 2026. Final street list depends on bids in early 2027. Delaware Avenue residents' request for concrete was not adopted; the segment stays an asphalt overlay. | Approved 7-0 |
| 14 | Asphalt program design (Contract 27-A) | OHM Advisors, not to exceed $167,700 (4.3% of the $3.9 million construction estimate), for 15 asphalt segments. | Approved 7-0 |
| 15 | Concrete program design (Contract 27-C) | Anderson, Eckstein & Westrick, Inc. (AEW), not to exceed $217,500, for 22 concrete reconstruction segments. | Approved 7-0 |
| 16 | Selective slab design (Contract 27-J) | AEW, not to exceed $79,500, for concrete maintenance on 14 segments, much of it on westbound Schoolcraft as MDOT's I-96/M-14 work wraps up. | Approved 7-0 |
| 17 | Spartan National rezoning | Petition 2026-07-01-03 to rezone 19250, 19288 and 19292 Farmington Road, east side between Seven Mile and Gable, from N-2 (Neighborhood) to C-2 (General Business) for a retail building. Public hearing held Oct. 12. The Planning Commission recommended approval. The draft ordinance's legal description lists 19259 Farmington Road where the agenda lists 19250. | First reading given; no vote |
| # | Item | Details | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 18 | Optalis Healthcare rezoning | Petition 2026-06-01-01 to rezone the rear 25 feet of 11687, 11709, 11731, 11741 and 11755 Camden from N-1 to C-1 for parking at the Fountain Bleu Health and Rehabilitation Center, north side of Plymouth Road between Camden and Haller. Planning Commission recommended approval 5-1. | Denied 7-0 |
| 19 | Guggenheim Development (Jiffy Lube) rezoning | Petition 2026-06-01-02 to rezone 32520 Seven Mile Road from C-1 to C-2 for an automotive service center. Planning Commission recommended denial. The developer offered a statement of conditions limiting C-2 zoning to the Jiffy Lube site plan, with no overnight vehicle storage and building-mounted lighting only. | Denied 5-2 |
| 20 | Emerson Oaks bond release | Release of $38,300 to Emerson Oaks – Livonia, LLC: paving $22,300, entrance markers/landscaping $5,000, monuments and markers $1,000, as-built drawings $10,000. The soil erosion bond is handled separately; Zilincik put it at about $6,000, and the bond schedule lists $5,400. | Tabled to Nov. 23, 7-0 |
| 21 | Lyndon Park bond release | Release of the $10,000 as-built drawings bond to Adams Park Development LLC for the Lyndon Park site condominium, south of Lyndon Avenue and east of Harrison Road. Closes out the project; the soil erosion bond is handled separately. | Approved 7-0 |
| 22 | Sidewalk trip hazards | Additional $20,000 from the non-motorized paths account, raising Precision Concrete Cutting, Inc.'s 2026 contract (26-G) from $30,000 to a not-to-exceed $50,000, for saw-cutting raised sidewalk in Section 24. | Approved 7-0 |
| 23 | Closed meeting | Closed Committee of the Whole meeting, set in the packet resolution for Nov. 16, 2026, at 6 p.m., to discuss the Law Department's legal opinion on Schostak/MPV's request to amend a consent judgment. Requires a two-thirds roll call vote under the Open Meetings Act. | Approved 7-0 |
Reports received and filed
- Department of Finance communication dated Oct. 16, 2026, forwarding the quarterly investment report for the quarter ending Aug. 31, 2026.
- Department of Finance communication dated Oct. 23, 2026, forwarding financial statements for the month ending July 31, 2026.
Every vote
| Time | Motion | Moved | Supported | Result | No votes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7:17 | Approve Oct. 26 regular meeting minutes | Ptashnik | McCullough | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 15:35 | Refer kratom to the Public Safety and Health Committee | Ptashnik | Budzinski | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 20:44 | Consent agenda, items 1-12 | McCullough | Persiconi | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 21:24 | Item 13, approve 2027 Road Repair Program | Budzinski | Persiconi | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 27:53 | Item 14, OHM asphalt design contract | Budzinski | Brockway | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 28:48 | Item 15, AEW concrete design contract | Ptashnik | Persiconi | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 29:24 | Item 16, AEW selective slab design contract | Budzinski | Ptashnik | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 30:36 | Item 17, first reading of Spartan National ordinance | Offered from the dais; speaker not identified in the transcript | First reading; no vote | n/a | |
| 31:35 | Item 18, deny Optalis rezoning | Brockway | Persiconi | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 33:04 | Item 19, deny Guggenheim (Jiffy Lube) rezoning | Budzinski | Brockway | Passed 5-2 | Ptashnik, McCullough |
| 53:13 | Item 20, deny Emerson Oaks bond release | McCullough | McDonnell | Withdrawn | n/a |
| 58:14 | Item 20, table to Nov. 23 | McCullough | Persiconi | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 1:11:38 | Item 21, release Lyndon Park bond | Persiconi | Ptashnik (name unclear in transcript) | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 1:13:03 | Item 22, additional sidewalk expenditure | Ptashnik (name unclear in transcript) | Persiconi | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 1:15:50 | Item 23, schedule closed Committee of the Whole | Not identified in transcript | Persiconi | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 1:24:46 | Grant Karen Greenwald one additional minute to speak | Brockway | McCullough | Passed 7-0 | None |
| 1:31:25 | Adjourn | Persiconi | Ptashnik | Adjourned | No roll call recorded |
Roll call: Councilmembers Robin Persiconi, Martha Ptashnik, Eileen McDonnell, Brandon McCullough and Carrie Budzinski, Vice President Patrick Brockway and President Kayleigh Reid. Times are elapsed time in the meeting video.
Council member updates
- 13:41 President Reid announced new data on item 19 and a public hearing on Monday, Nov. 23, at 6 p.m. in the auditorium. She warned that people are impersonating city officials to get money and pointed residents to livonia.gov/directory to verify contacts.
- 14:10 Budzinski said her final in-person coffee hour of the year is Saturday, Nov. 14, at the Civic Center Library, which she said she believed starts at 11 a.m. in the Michigan Room. She is collecting canned pumpkin, cat food and pads for an animal shelter drive run by an animal awareness club at Madonna University.
- 14:55 Persiconi congratulated the Stevenson boys soccer team, which she said won the city, Lakes Valley Conference division and conference, and MHSAA district and regional titles before losing the state final 2-1 on Saturday, Nov. 7, to an undefeated opponent.
- 15:35 Ptashnik said residents had contacted her about kratom and she had seen it in the high school. She said it is sold in gas stations to all ages, acts as a stimulant with opioid-like effects, and is not regulated by Michigan law, and moved to send it to the Public Safety and Health Committee to study sales, locations and age limits. The motion passed 7-0.
- 16:50 Brockway said he had asked the administration whether $40,000 approved for Noble Library repairs had been spent. He said two resolutions, one in 2024 and one in 2025, funded an environmental assessment for mold and asbestos, electrical panel work that restored lights and a sump pump, gutter and downspout cleaning, and $16,800 in property condition assessments by a consultant, totaling about $48,000 in his account.
- 18:16 McDonnell had no announcements.
- 18:21 McCullough said his senior pizza event is Nov. 19, with registration through Parks and Recreation. He congratulated Franklin football on winning a district title and Stevenson soccer on finishing state runner-up. He said he presented at a national facilities management conference in Las Vegas the previous week, and announced a May 15 game between the Livonia All-Stars and Red Wings alumni, with details to come.
Public comment
Opening audience communication
- 8:20 Noah Joseph Wojcik, Brookfield Street, praised early voting at City Hall, including curbside voting, but said his parents and friends reported that the general election at the Riley polling site (Precinct 10) had a 45-minute wait, three to five precincts in one building, people leaving without voting and little help for voters with disabilities. He said he is a precinct delegate there and asked that it be improved before next year's city elections.
- 10:35 Mike Martin, Trillium, who said he worked 33 years in engineering at Ford, spoke about holding convictions with humility and testing assumptions. He said he stands with an American flag and a sign from 1 to 2 p.m. on Saturdays and invites people who disagree with him to meet at the Livonia library at noon.
Item 19, Jiffy Lube rezoning
- 34:23 Elizabeth Rogers, Taft Stettinius & Hollister, Southfield, counsel for the developer: the statement of conditions makes C-2 apply only to the Jiffy Lube site plan; the site plan is heavily landscaped; 23 letters of support, including adjacent business owners.
- 36:36 Tim Rossi, Guggenheim Development, Frisco, Texas: the firm develops Jiffy Lubes and opens them; a strip center on the site would likely seek a drive-through end cap and could draw uses such as vape shops.
- 38:11 Jim Biga, Livonia: opposed; C-2 sets a precedent next to apartments and homes; suggested the former Ram's Horn site or vacant land near I-275 instead.
- 40:06 Jerry Karasinski, Bainbridge Avenue: opposed; no automotive businesses within a square mile, and the use does not fit the neighborhood.
- 40:51 Cindy Fleming, Livonia: opposed; cited the memory care facility at 32500 Seven Mile, an assisted living facility, apartments and school bus stops.
- 41:45 John Pastor, owner of the Scooter's Coffee property at 19100 Farmington Road: in favor; said the zoning reverts to C-1 if the project fails, the business is open 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. with about four cars an hour, no resident within 300 feet objected, and the memory care and long-term care operators sent support letters.
- 43:53 Denise Mika, Livonia: opposed; said school buses run on the road after 8 a.m., that the rezoning would invite similar requests, and that walkability is what residents want.
- 45:11 Rogers again: the statement of conditions is recorded and runs with the land, so no other developer could build under the C-2 zoning; the building sits near the street with landscaping toward homes.
- 47:54 Jason Daye, Excel Engineering, Fond du Lac, Wisconsin: about 40 vehicle trips a day split between two driveways; two-thirds of the site stays green space with irrigated landscaping.
Item 20, Emerson Oaks
- 1:01:01 Chris Muldoon, Tulipwood, for the homeowners association: the road is crumbling four years in and taxpayers will repair it; the city is replacing Harrison Road sidewalk flags he said the developer damaged; the west-side berm is too steep to mow; the northwest corner floods.
- 1:03:09 Tom Jones, Emerson Court: the monument sign is loose with letters dangling; grass has not grown in the common areas, where he said seed and straw were laid over concrete and sewers; seven trees are missing and many are dead; the berm was built from clay excavated for basements.
- 1:05:19 Nelson Edwards, Tulipwood: grass by the pond is not maintained and draws ducks; no fence keeps the public from cutting through yards; the entrance looked neglected for three years.
Item 21, Lyndon Park
- 1:11:54 Cindy Fleming noted that a Lyndon Park resident who spoke at the previous meeting about the bonds was not present.
Closing audience communication
- 1:16:38 Frank McDermott asked council to put on its next agenda a rescission of the lifetime ban barring Steve King from the Senior Wellness Center and recreation center. He said King paid a $50 fine and court costs in 16th District Court on the underlying trespassing charge.
- 1:18:38 Danielle Lucido, Livonia, of Protective Parents Michigan (the transcript also renders her surname as "Cato"), said November is Family Court Awareness Month and asked the city to proclaim it next year. She cited a Michigan law named for a Caledonia boy, Rowan, that she said was signed July 23, 2026, and urged adoption of Kayden's Law, which would require judges to be trained on abuse, including coercive control.
- 1:21:29 Karen Greenwald, founder of Access Livonia Now 504, who said she is legally partially blind and reads her statement with a screen reader, said she intends to file a federal disability discrimination suit. She said City Clerk Lori Miller called police on Oct. 27 while she was collecting signatures at the Civic Center Library for barrier-free voting tables, and that police accused her of things she said did not happen. She also said City Attorney Eric Goldstein made statements about her that she described as stereotyping. Council voted 7-0 to give her one more minute. No city official responded at the meeting.
- 1:26:58 Denise Mika said she was embarrassed by how council handled Greenwald's request for extra time and asked members to show speakers more grace.
- 1:28:22 Sonny Bertoni, for Spartan National, asked about next steps on item 17 and was told the first reading is the first step and staff would contact him.
- 1:29:07 Laura Danica, Munger Street, said she was beside Greenwald when police arrived and officers asked, "Are you Karen?" She said someone inside City Hall must have called them. She said Greenwald has worked on accessibility for ten years.
- 1:30:48 Annette Roberts, Livonia, said she was the person inside City Hall, and that a woman in a wheelchair and her daughter "were threatened by Karen" and came in upset and frightened, which she said preceded the police call.
Dates ahead
- Monday, Nov. 16, 6 p.m.: closed Committee of the Whole on the Schostak/MPV consent judgment, per the packet resolution.
- Thursday, Nov. 19: McCullough's senior pizza event, registration through Parks and Recreation.
- Monday, Nov. 23, 6 p.m.: public hearing, City Hall auditorium; regular meeting to follow, with the Emerson Oaks bond release back on the agenda.
Comments are open below.

