Planning Commission recommends data center rules and Five Mile condo to Council
LIVONIA — 11/14/2026
Commissioners recommended data center rules and a zoning moratorium ordinance to City Council, recommended approval of a 14-unit condominium on Five Mile Road over neighbors' objections, adopted a housing chapter for the master plan and tabled a Farmington Road renovation.
LIVONIA — The Livonia City Planning Commission voted 5-0 on Tuesday, Nov. 10, to recommend that City Council adopt zoning rules for data centers, which Chairman Ian Wilshaw said the commission drafted over many meetings at Council's request. The recommendation sets residential buffers by size, closes a noise-ordinance exemption for cooling equipment and, as amended at the meeting, would allow data centers as a waiver use in M-1 light industrial zoning as well as M-2. City Council makes the final decision.
The commission also voted 5-0 to recommend Council approval of a 14-unit townhome condominium at 27480 Five Mile Road, after five neighboring residents spoke about the loss of woods, drainage, density and privacy. It recommended an ordinance setting the terms for zoning moratoria, adopted Book 5, Housing Sustainability, as an amendment to the Livonia Vision 21 Master Plan, and tabled a petition to renovate the office building at 19900 Farmington Road until Dec. 8.
Five of seven commissioners attended: Wilshaw, Secretary Sam Caramagno, Wafa Dinaro, Patrick Droze and Peter H. Ventura. Vice Chair Glen W. Long Jr. and David Bongero did not answer the roll call, and every roll-call vote was recorded with five members. Before taking up the agenda, Wilshaw paid tribute to former Mayor Jack Kirksey.
Summary of actions
The agenda has no sections labeled consent, unfinished or new business. Its headings are Miscellaneous Items, Pending Items, the 2027 schedule and minutes. The categories below are this report's grouping: Pending Items, which were tabled at earlier meetings, are listed as unfinished business, and Miscellaneous Items as new business.
| Category | Item | Outcome | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consent agenda | None | Not applicable | The Nov. 10 agenda has no consent agenda. The two routine items (2027 schedule and minutes) were each approved on a separate motion, by consent with no objection. |
| New business: tabled | Item 1. Petition 2026-10-08-04, H&A Investments LLC, site plan approval under Section 3.10 to renovate the office building at 19900 Farmington Road, northeast corner of Farmington Road and Fargo Street, into a multi-tenant retail building | Tabled to Dec. 8, 5-0 | The 3,750-square-foot building, zoned C-1 (Local Business), would be split into three units of 1,273, 1,204 and 1,273 square feet, with no change to the footprint and no tenants proposed in the petition; the owner said the corner unit would house the owner's own brokerage. Proposed exterior: new storefront glass in black aluminum frames, light gray manufactured stone, horizontal wood-tone siding and dark charcoal metal panels. Ventura moved to table because the petitioner had not submitted an updated site plan, landscaping plan, photometric (lighting) plan, updated parking layout or on-site dumpster location. Next study meeting Dec. 1; next regular meeting Dec. 8. |
| New business: approving recommendation to City Council | Item 2. Petition 2026-10-08-05, Tahir Khan on behalf of Oasisbuild, LLC, site plan approval under Section 3.07 for a 14-unit multi-family residential condominium at 27480 Five Mile Road, north side of Five Mile between Greenlane Street and Foch Avenue, southeast quarter of Section 13 | Recommended approval with conditions, 5-0 | Fourteen two-story townhomes in three rows on a vacant 1.6-acre lot, each with a one-car garage, a 10-by-10-foot rear patio and privacy fencing between units; a fenced 20-by-40-foot dog run; seven parallel guest spaces; underground stormwater detention under the drive. The resolution approves the plan sheets "subject to City Council approval" and adds standard conditions: irrigated and maintained landscaping, perimeter screening (a 6-foot masonry wall or opaque fence, or a 20-foot greenbelt with one tree per 20 linear feet, at least half evergreen, subject to Council review), the master deed and bylaws filed with the city, and a one-year approval period from Council approval. Conditions added at the meeting: move the dumpster toward Five Mile Road, modify the plan for a fire apparatus turnaround, add landscaping along the east side and remove guest parking spaces between buildings for fire access. |
| Unfinished business: approving recommendation to City Council | Item 3. Petition 2026-06-06-01, zoning ordinance amendments to define and regulate data centers, including the districts where they may locate and special requirements | Recommended approval, with optional condition 2, 5-0 | Taken from the table. Requires a 1,000-foot residential buffer for data centers over 100,000 square feet or 15 megawatts and a 300-foot buffer for smaller ones. Low-frequency sound (under 200 Hz) requires a sound study; sound over 200 Hz falls under the existing noise ordinance; data center cooling and processing equipment is written out of the noise ordinance's mechanical-equipment exemption. Optional condition 2, added at the meeting, allows data centers as a waiver use in M-1 as well as M-2. Optional condition 1, which would have reduced the setbacks, was not added. |
| Unfinished business: approving recommendation to City Council | Item 4. Petition 2026-08-06-02, new Section 13.16 setting the means and reasoning for zoning moratoria | Recommended approval, 5-0 | Taken from the table. A moratorium must rest on specific, substantiated concerns from credentialed experts or substantial evidence. Maximum length cut from one year to six months, with up to two three-month extensions. Council must end a moratorium as soon as the threat is found to have passed. The resolution calls moratoria "disfavored as a routine zoning tool." |
| Unfinished business: adopted | Item 5. Petition 2026-01-07-01, Livonia Vision 21 Master Plan amendment, Book 5, Housing Sustainability | Adopted, 5-0 | Taken from the table. The resolution as read states the commission "hereby adopts" Book 5, including revisions it approved Nov. 10, following its Aug. 11, 2026 public hearing. Planning staff said the agenda's wording, which describes a request for Council authorization to distribute the draft, came from the original petition and that the item was for adoption. The agenda item also lists changes to the Future Land Use Map; the resolution as read names only Book 5. |
| Approved: routine | Item 6. 2027 Planning Commission schedule | Approved, no objection | Meetings every other week, alternating study and public hearing meetings with a week off between, with back-to-back meetings around holidays. |
| Approved: routine | Item 7. Minutes of the 1,251st meeting, Oct. 13, 2026 | Approved, no objection | The chair said four members attended the Oct. 13 meeting and cited Robert's Rules to allow members who were absent to vote on the minutes. |
| Denied | None | None | No item was denied. |
Significant events
- Data center rules head to Council. The commission sent its draft to City Council with an approving recommendation. Wilshaw described it as a compromise between people who would prefer outright bans and others who would prefer unrestricted use. Ventura, who voted yes, said the city does not have 600 or 1,000 acres of vacant land and that the rules will in practice govern reuse of existing industrial buildings.
- Condo recommended over neighbors' objections. Five residents spoke on the Five Mile Road project. One said they strongly oppose it, and another asked the commission to delay or deny it. The commission recommended approval with added conditions on the dumpster, fire access and east-side landscaping.
- Fire Marshal's comments not yet met. Ventura said the condominium plan before the commission did not accommodate all of the Fire Marshal's comments. The Fire Marshal's letter calls for a turnaround where a dead-end drive exceeds 150 feet and says the dumpster area is not adequate for one. The petitioner's representative said the plan would be revised and sent to the Fire Department before final drawings.
- Housing chapter adopted. Book 5 adds the housing element that state law now requires in master plans. The consultant said none of the revisions after public comment were substantial.
- Tribute to Jack Kirksey. Wilshaw spoke about the former mayor, whose death the Detroit Free Press reported Oct. 14, and the commission held a moment of silence.
19900 Farmington Road
The building is the southernmost of six built together as the Livonia Professional Plaza complex and now on separate parcels. The parcel is just over half an acre, with 166 feet on Farmington Road and 138 feet on Fargo Street. Single-family homes lie across Farmington to the west; the Woodlawn Condominiums lie across Fargo to the south. The site has 35 parking spaces and no barrier-free spaces, and the dumpster that serves it sits on a neighboring parcel to the north. Staff said the ordinance would require four trees, two ornamental trees and 28 shrubs along Farmington, and that no landscaping plan was submitted. Wall signs are proposed as illuminated channel letters, without dimensions.
The engineering, fire, police and inspection reviews raised no objections. The Inspection Department, in a letter signed by Director of Inspection Jerome Hanna, called for a screened dumpster enclosure at least 6 feet tall, lighting that limits spill to 0.5 foot-candle at the property line, irrigation, restriping and barrier-free parking including a van-accessible space.
The owner told commissioners the building was bought about two months ago and had sat without a tenant for at least 15 years, according to information the owner received. The owner plans to open a real estate brokerage in the corner unit, said the other names on the drawings were placeholders, and said the architect needed about two weeks to complete revised plans. The owner said they have redeveloped properties in Livonia for 22 years and have three investments in the city.
Figures that differ
- Property taxes: A letter from City Treasurer Susan Nash, read by staff, says the owner still owes summer 2026 taxes of $5,565.65, due Sept. 14, 2026. Staff confirmed at the meeting that the taxes were outstanding. The owner said all delinquencies were paid through the title company. A separate letter listing $1,447.73 in unpaid water and sewer charges was accompanied by a receipt showing payment, staff said.
- Cross-access agreements: Ventura said it was Ventura's understanding from the study session that the owner did not have cross-easement agreements with the neighboring parcels. At this meeting, the owner said one had been received from the title company, and staff said the city has the agreements on record.
27480 Five Mile Road condominium
What was proposed
Planning staff said the lot is about 200 feet wide on Five Mile Road and up to about 370 feet deep, zoned N-1 (Neighborhood Multifamily). A 16-unit condominium was approved on the site in 2006 and never built. The plan shows a south row of six units facing Five Mile, a middle row of six facing north and two units at the rear facing south. Units are L-shaped, 32.5 by 22 feet, with a family room, dining room, kitchen and powder room on the first floor and an owner's suite, two more bedrooms, a full bath and laundry on the second. After the study session, the facade was changed to stone veneer on the first floor and engineered wood siding on the second, and a gazebo was replaced with the dog run.
A single drive enters from Five Mile and runs along the east side to the rear. The lighting plan shows fixtures 15 feet tall and a maximum of 3 foot-candles under them. The landscaping plan shows 22 evergreen trees and 21 arborvitae on the perimeter, plus five trees, two ornamental trees and 35 shrubs on Five Mile. Part of the wooded rear of the site would be left in its natural state, a strip commissioners were told is just under 50 feet deep. The plan shows chain-link fence on the north and an existing concrete wall on the southwest, with 6 feet between the drive and the east property line.
The Engineering Division said no sanitary or storm calculations had been submitted, so it could not comment on effects on existing systems, and that the storm system must meet the Wayne County stormwater ordinance. The Treasurer's office said summer 2026 taxes of $1,252.88 remain unpaid on the property. Staff said a number of written public comments were provided to commissioners and are in the packet on the city's website.
The petitioner
Mike Spencer, representing Oasis Healthcare, told commissioners the company runs assisted living facilities in Michigan and another state and builds affordable single-family housing in other cities, and is moving into multifamily housing. Spencer said the company would move the dumpster so a ladder truck can turn around, leave out a parking space and move the dog run to open fire access between buildings, and submit a revised plan to the Fire Department. The siding is a recycled composite with a 30- or 40-year warranty, Spencer said, the stone runs 8 feet high, garage doors are insulated aluminum with a wood finish, and the roof is standing-seam metal. Colors have not been chosen; Spencer described limestone grays and tans, bronze siding and a black roof, and promised samples.
Responding to residents, Spencer said not all the woods would be removed, that a property management company would replace dead trees, and that lighting would be directed away from neighbors. Stormwater, Spencer said, would collect in 48- or 60-inch pipes under the drive and drain to the street through a restricted outlet sized by the Department of Public Works, and catch basins would intercept water coming out of neighboring yards, which Spencer said should improve their drainage. Spencer said the existing chain-link fence is 48 inches tall and no taller fence is planned, so wildlife can pass. Dog owners would be required to pick up waste, and the property manager would monitor the dog run. Droze, noting the land falls from west to east, asked how much of the runoff crossing the site would be accounted for; Spencer said 100%, in the stormwater calculations. Asked by Ventura about the east side, Spencer agreed to denser tree planting there rather than a solid wall.
Data center ordinance
Jacob Uhazie of the city's planning department said data centers are now treated as a permitted use in both commercial and industrial districts. The draft makes 11 changes to the zoning ordinance. The only changes since the last meeting, Uhazie said, were to sound: frequencies over 200 Hz fall under the existing noise ordinance, frequencies under 200 Hz still require a sound study, and new language closes the mechanical-equipment exemption in Section 8.32 of the Code of Ordinances so that a data center's heating, cooling and processing equipment cannot claim it. Uhazie said the 1,000-foot buffer leaves more than 600 acres in M-2 districts for large data centers, and the 300-foot buffer leaves more than 1,000 acres for smaller ones. A Department of Public Works representative attended for questions on water use; none were asked.
Ventura asked that the motion include both optional conditions in the prepared resolution. Wilshaw described option 1 as reducing the setbacks for different sizes of data centers and option 2 as allowing the use as a waiver use in M-1 as well as M-2. Caramagno, who made the motion, said a developer could appeal the setback to the Zoning Board of Appeals, and staff agreed nothing would prevent that. Caramagno accepted option 2 and not option 1. A commissioner said the ordinance's requirements for documenting impacts back up the buffer, and that if a developer comes to the ZBA, its noise provisions would protect residents.
Wilshaw said the ordinance addresses noise, power use, water use and decommissioning of sites that stop operating as data centers, and is "not Saline," "not Southfield" and "not Wixom." Ventura, citing 47 years in commercial real estate, said there are not 600 or 1,000 acres of vacant land in the city, that a data center would require buying and demolishing developed property, which Ventura called "economically totally unfeasible," and that the Saline project is 1.2 million square feet on a thousand acres. Ventura said the ordinance is "a fine ordinance."
The section list differs between the agenda and the motion. The agenda and the secretary's reading list Sections 2.02, 3.03, 3.10, 3.11, 3.12, 3.13, 3.15, 3.16, 3.17 and 6.61. The motion as read also names Sections 2.01 and 6.6. The resolution says the amendments work in conjunction with amendments to Chapter 13.04 of the Code of Ordinances.
Zoning moratoria ordinance
Staff said the draft was revised after the study session to require that any moratorium rest on specific, substantiated concerns from credentialed experts or substantial evidence, to cut the maximum length from one year to six months with up to two three-month extensions, and to require Council to act immediately to end a moratorium once the threat has passed rather than let it run out. Droze's resolution says a moratorium "temporarily suspends property owners' rights to develop or build" and "must be derived by dire and impending threat to the public health, safety and welfare." The agenda describes adding Section 13.16; the motion as read describes amending it.
Master plan: Book 5, Housing Sustainability
Uhazie said 16 more people commented after the commission extended the comment period at its Aug. 11 meeting, with a recurring emphasis on preserving established neighborhoods, existing housing and community character. Wilshaw said the extension was sought because no written comments had arrived before the hearing, and that the administration promoted the plan on social media.
Donovan Smith of the consulting firm McKenna said a recent amendment to the state planning act requires a housing component in master plans, and that the city is also at its five-year review. Book 5 keeps the Vision 21 goals for housing and neighborhoods and for urban design and adds a third, housing sustainability, which Smith defined as maintaining Livonia's housing fabric and character over the long run. Smith said a community survey drew 557 responses, and that the plan identifies a need for four-bedroom units and for studios and one-bedroom units, emphasizes market-rate housing on existing and vacant sites, and shows examples of how large privately owned sites the city does not control could be used for housing or mixed use. Smith said none of the revisions were substantial.
Dinaro's resolution says an updated housing component is a statutory requirement and is needed for eligibility for certain state and federal grants.
Roll-call votes
All motions carried. Long and Bongero were absent for each. Times are the roll call, or the chair's call for objections. Votes are listed in the order called. Motions to take items from the table, the schedule, the minutes and adjournment were decided by consent with no objection.
| Recording time | Motion | Mover / Support | Vote | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30:50 | Table Petition 2026-10-08-04 (19900 Farmington Road) to Dec. 8 | Ventura / Droze | Yes: Ventura, Droze, Dinaro, Caramagno, Wilshaw | 5-0 |
| 1:29:03 | Approving resolution, Petition 2026-10-08-05 (27480 Five Mile Road), with added conditions, to City Council | Caramagno / Dinaro | Yes: Caramagno, Dinaro, Droze, Ventura, Wilshaw | 5-0 |
| 1:30:44 | Take Petition 2026-06-06-01 (data centers) from the table | Droze / Ventura | No objection | Carried, 5 present |
| 1:46:35 | Approving resolution, Petition 2026-06-06-01 (data centers), with optional condition 2, to City Council | Caramagno / Dinaro | Yes: Caramagno, Dinaro, Droze, Ventura, Wilshaw | 5-0 |
| 1:47:51 | Take Petition 2026-08-06-02 (moratoria) from the table | Dinaro / Droze | No objection | Carried, 5 present |
| 1:51:50 | Approving resolution, Petition 2026-08-06-02 (moratoria), to City Council | Droze / Ventura | Yes: Droze, Ventura, Dinaro, Caramagno, Wilshaw | 5-0 |
| 1:52:51 | Take Petition 2026-01-07-01 (Book 5) from the table | Not clear on the recording / Droze | No objection; Dinaro had stepped away | Carried, 4 present |
| 2:11:04 | Adopt Book 5, Housing Sustainability, as a Vision 21 Master Plan amendment | Dinaro / Droze | Yes: Dinaro, Droze, Ventura, Caramagno, Wilshaw | 5-0 |
| 2:12:31 | Approve the 2027 Planning Commission schedule | Dinaro / Ventura | No objection | Carried, 5-0 |
| 2:13:43 | Approve minutes of the Oct. 13, 2026 meeting | Ventura / Droze | No objection | Carried, 5-0 |
| 2:14:13 | Adjourn | Ventura / Dinaro | No objection | Adjourned 9:15 p.m. |
Public comment
Times are positions in the meeting recording. Comment was taken on the two Miscellaneous Items. Pending Items are not open to public comment unless the commission votes to allow it, Wilshaw said. Residents' house numbers are left out.
- 26:28 Keith Panetta asked whether the 19900 Farmington Road unit with a kitchen would have outdoor seating. Staff said only limited-service restaurants are allowed there and minimal outdoor seating needs no waiver; Wilshaw said that would mean something like a coffee shop with a couple of tables.
- 52:58 Jonathan Demetriou, whose home backs onto the woods, told commissioners, "I strongly, strongly oppose this 14 unit condominium development." Demetriou said the woods behind the home were a primary reason for buying it, that the family regularly sees deer and wild turkey, and that neighbors made the same choice. Demetriou asked how to read the written comments; staff said they are in the packet on the city's website.
- 55:18 Troy Buono, a 40-year resident on the north side of the site, said Buono bought part of the property from the earlier developer and a neighbor bought a section behind their homes to stop that development. Buono asked whether a fence would go in on the north. Staff said the north end would stay wooded, with chain-link fence and landscape screening around the site.
- 58:12 Jeff Douglas, a Greenlane Street resident northeast of the site, asked the commission to delay or deny the project. Douglas raised the loss of woods that screen the neighborhood from Five Mile Road, the density of 14 units on 1.6 acres, ground floors smaller than the 624 square feet Douglas said is required for two-story homes (Douglas said total floor area does exceed the 1,200 required), the lack of a traffic study (staff confirmed none was received), speeding near Five Mile and Inkster Road, yard flooding on clay soil, the age and upkeep of screening trees, second-floor windows overlooking yards, and light in an area Douglas said is near-dark at night.
- 1:09:05 A Foch Avenue resident north of the site said four properties there have standing water and cannot be mowed until July, supported moving the dumpster toward Five Mile, and asked about dog sizes, waste cleanup and the height of the north fence, citing deer that cross to Five Mile. The chair said dog rules would be up to the condominium's bylaws, and staff said the plan does not show the fence height.
- 1:12:37 A resident who had already spoken returned to say Foch has no sidewalks and the Greenlane side has only partial sidewalks, and that more traffic and overflow parking would endanger children, including the speaker's three young children. The speaker supported Douglas's call for a traffic study.
- 1:14:20 Alex Cleveland, a Greenlane Street resident of 40 years whose backyard adjoins the site, said bedrooms in the ranch homes on Greenlane and Foch back up to the property and would get the light, that 14 units are too many, and that fewer units built toward Five Mile would cause less harm. Cleveland showed commissioners photos of spring flooding in the yard and asked where plowed snow would go.
- 1:16:52 Spencer responded for the petitioner (see above). Snow would be piled at the end of the fire turnaround with a catch basin, Spencer said.
Commissioner comments
The Planning Commission has no council members. These are commissioners' and staff remarks outside the motions.
- 2:40 Wilshaw paid tribute to former Mayor Jack Kirksey. Wilshaw said Kirksey appointed Wilshaw to the Traffic Commission as a young man and later made Wilshaw its chairman, and that Kirksey started the mayor's Rapid Response Meetings, which bring together members of Council, the Planning Commission, the Zoning Board of Appeals and department heads to give prospective business owners early feedback and which still continue. Wilshaw called Kirksey "one of the funniest and wittiest people," recalled State of the City addresses that filled the room with laughter, spoke of his late wife, Pat, and offered condolences to his children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren. The commission held a moment of silence.
- 1:38:53 Wilshaw, before the data center vote, thanked staff, colleagues and residents who spoke, and said the draft is a compromise that "fits Livonia," giving the city enforceable tools while letting private businesses operate.
- 1:42:05 A commissioner said the ordinance's mitigation and documentation requirements back up the buffer, and that its noise provisions would protect residents if a developer came to the ZBA.
- 1:43:18 Ventura, repeating an observation Ventura said had been made twice before, said that the acreage figures describe developed land, not vacant land, and that the ordinance in practice governs reuse of existing industrial buildings.
- 1:54:11 Wilshaw thanked residents who spoke at the August hearing on Book 5 and those who submitted written comments, many with edits and corrections.
- 2:11:50 Staff said the alternating schedule worked this year and gives petitioners time to update plans between meetings.
- 2:14:22 Wilshaw thanked Livonia television staff for broadcasting the meeting and adjourned it at 9:15 p.m.
What's next
The condominium, data center and moratoria recommendations go to City Council, which makes the final decisions. Wilshaw told residents to watch the Council agenda for the condominium, where they will have a chance to speak. The 19900 Farmington Road petition returns at the Dec. 1 study meeting and the Dec. 8 regular meeting if revised plans are submitted.
Sources: City of Livonia Nov. 10, 2026 Planning Commission meeting recording and agenda; city Planning Commission roster; city Inspection and Treasurer's Office directories; Detroit Free Press, Oct. 14, 2026.

